Why Labour are also fuck-ups

So, seeing I’ve been strongly critical of national on women’s rights, let’s do a retrospective of similar areas where Labour fucked up on identity politics, political freedom and non-discrimination. I have the feeling this is going to make me temporarily popular with certain other Greens who share with me a deep distrust of Labour, and of course I’m sure the National Partisans will laugh it up at both what I believe and the fact that I’m absolutely going to town on Labour. Don’t worry, you’re still in the targets, too. 😉

  • Pay Equity (for women): They essentially started the investigation into pay equity in the public service to make the problem go away until next term. Except that was stupid: Labour ran a healthy surplus for most of its terms in government, an ideal time to implement the increase in public sector wages that would be the simplest way to address direct pay equity issues. Not only that, but they knew they had a pretty good chance at being ousted coming up to their third bid for re-election, so if pay equity is as important as they’re implying, they should have put it on their list to fast-track before the election. Overall their reluctance to act on an issue even the most anti-feminist of women would appreciate in some sense has been inexcusable, and it made their criticism on this issue pretty hollow.
  • Seabed and Foreshore: Confiscating these was a disaster. Even if you accept they needed to be nationalised in some form rather than being claimed in settlement, the government should have at least let Maori have their day in court first and compensated Maori with something else in settlements if they did have a good claim. And even if nationalisation of some sort did go ahead, the seabed and foreshore should have been placed into the public domain (where everybody effectively owns it and has usage rights) rather than vested to the crown. (where we all just have to trust no government decides to do something incredibly dumb with it) Overall a fuck-up of massive proportions even if you didn’t want any seabed and foreshore claims going ahead. Not only that, but reversing this thing is part of the reason National doesn’t have to rely on the Greens to pass anything that Act don’t want to- both in the sense of the existence of the Maori Party, and in the sense of their willingness to form a coalition with National.
  • Marriage is still straight-only: And labour defended it as straight-only. I don’t see why we didn’t go whole-hog on this, civil unions lead that way eventually, and giving space to idiots like Gordon Copeland and Brian Tamaki only encourages them. Make them steam it out.
  • The bill of rights is still only paid lip service: The most ridiculous of bills are found consistent with the bill of rights that even a budding civil rights activist could see are not. If we’re going to maintain the idea that the bill of rights should limit the power of Parliament, let’s actually have at it. For one, we should be having judicial overrulings of implied restrictions of straight marriages for transwomen and transmen, and gay marriage. For another, Three Strikes should be disallowed if it passes. Labour made no move to tighten up our constitution here, and they deserve some of the blame for not doing enough every time National and its most extreme coalition partner rub it in their face with legislation with terrible civil liberties connotations.
  • No checks on Parliament’s power: As the academic and social elite of New Zealand, (as opposed to the financial and social elite, who they sit opposite to) Labour seems to think that Parliament knows best, and even the biggest partisan reformists are reluctant to act quickly and decisively on any constitutional reform. The lack of any meaningful review of laws leads to low-quality legislation as there is no disincentive to sloppy drafting, and only select committees save us from elected dictatorships as it is. More oversight of Parliament is necessary, and I don’t just mean opening the books to OIA requests. Unfortunately, the phrase “constutional reform” sets off monarchists even if it’s unrelated to a Republic, and Labour didn’t have the guts.
  • The EFA: While unlike many from the Right and Centre I don’t think law touched free speech with a ten-foot pole, and I supported the general motivations behind it, there were three big problems with this law.
    • Was not radical or tough enough: If Parliament was going to get tough on electoral laws, they should have gone whole-hog. Instead we have anonymous donations below a thousand dollars in a world where donating anything to a political party is an extraordinary act of partisanship for most. Donations through filter trusts may still evade pubic scrutiny of their real sources, and the loopholes in the EFA are generally still big enough to run a train through.
    • Poor drafting and implementation: Before I get to the political part, this law should probably have set every-year all-year caps at a more sensible rate on both party and issue campaigning. Beyond that, Labour left notification laws a muddle, and the procedure for dealing with them a farce, with even the minister responsible for the law being caught out on her opinions of what did or did not breach it very frequently.
    • Parliament should not regulate politics: If Labour had wanted to do this the proper way, rather than leave the Greens to negotiate a Citizen’s Jury into elecoral finance, they should have put all the relevant laws in the hands of a truly independent body with a similar structure and lobbied like any other interest group. That approach would have probably been a publicity boost, and if it left them with less cash in hand, it would be likely that experts would attempt to be equally hard on National’s large donors to equalise the playing field.
  • Gay adoption and provisions for other non-heteronormative families: This merited visiting in at least some manner after civil unions were passed.
  • Their list: While claiming to be a left party and generally supporting freedoms and championing the underprivileged, Labour betrays the strains of elitism that run through its more powerful tiers by retaining strict central control of their party list. One of the big, and legitimate, criticisms of MMP is that list candidates can be chosen entirely by backroom meeting in most parties. Righting it is as simple as adopting a postal ballot for your list and using it to encourage members to join. Labour should have joined the Greens in this long ago.
  • Prisons: Not only is Labour a staunch supporter of incubating more criminals with a policy of systematic over-incarceration and a justice policy based on vengeance rather than restoration of our community, but this is about the most likely aspect of their policy to get dramatically worse under Phil Goff.
  • Cannot really be called centre-left: Centre-left would imply that there are significant aspects of leftism remaining within the caucus and among senior party members. Labour has been a centre party and a staunch supporter of the flawed attempt at free-market capitalism that trade liberals have unleashed on the world since before MMP, and is remaining one after it. Only their focus on reducing unemployment and their staunch social liberals make them a positive force in parliament. (although that’s a pretty big “only”)
  • Environmentally kleptocratic: Despite their big promises of cleaning up New Zealand and moving towards sustainability, Labour put much more effort towards economic development and paid bare lip service to minimising global warming with their softball ETS that was hardly worth supporting.

Now, keep in mind that this is a very complete list in its strongest and most general form. Largely speaking, I think Labour is the third-best Party in Parliament and actually does more good than harm. I think that its policies for the middle class, its Keynesian streak, its financial (if not economic) management of the country, and its tax system are all very good “second bests”. Most of the MPs individually are good people who I have a lot of commonality with politically, they just have enough specifics wrong to drive me half-insane watching them failing so close to getting it right. Presumably even a pretty good government would generate a list at least have as long, and I think this last government has to be admitted as having managed okay on a fair amonut of issues by most of its critics.

But I have deep reservations on the current direction of the Labour Party, its priorities, its conduct, and its trustworthiness, and would not vote for it under any system where I had an ability to really choose another party. Labour has lost its hang of defending civil liberties, privacies, and its social liberals are mired beneath the free trade academics who think they can get a good deal for the country’s working class through imaginary infinite growth. It’s not gonna happen Labour, and you need to stop thinking that anything but a physically static economy can be branded with the word “sustainable”.mong

Advertisements

5 Responses

  1. Couldn’t agree with you more. Labour are the problem. Moreso than National, because Labour (deliberately?) stand in the way of real change.

    I would add factory farming to the list above too. It’s not a comprehensive one 😉

  2. Well, it’s comprehensive in the sense I didn’t leave things off because I’m too lazy to list them. Factory farming didn’t even come to mind, sadly- probably because I’m used to nobody wanting to do about it. Which I shouldn’t have to be 😡

  3. Bitches ain’t SHIT but Hoes and tricks…..
    They think they are so super SICK with IT….
    Tell them to run the TRACK……
    Cause I run real Fast….like DERRICK SO FOR REAL!!!!!
    They called me and my girl LIGHTENING SKILLS…..
    Just ask my cousin Marcus Fields……
    FAMILY TIES are So strong……
    They keep me writing these damn songs….
    OVER and OVER again!!!
    I am a BALLA BABY……
    So go run tell that……
    I passed my TEST…..
    I am a million dollar make you wanna holla CHICK!!!!!
    I don’t need damn man….
    Cuz they running the same damn SONGS…….

    Tis ain’t no damn rerun…..
    So keep to steeping baby and say my NAME…..
    My men LOVE me baby….
    Did you know THAT???

    BITCHES AIN’T SHIT BUT HOES AND TRICKS
    They are so super sic in the street….
    and I give it to them because I can’t compete!
    I run the Damn SHOW HOE!!!!!
    A1 sauce is the BEST steak SAUCE but for his LOVE it cost baby!!!!!
    I represent the whole damn SHEBANG.,….
    it’s like Tang baby so say my name….

    Bulls baby we go REAL HARD and I can go HARDER if you want me too….
    now baby I just schooled you FOOL!!!!!

  4. UPS works GREAT
    So go run tell that……
    I passed my TEST…..
    I am a million dollar make you wanna holla CHICK!!!!!
    I don’t need damn man….
    Cuz they running the same damn SONGS…….

    Tis ain’t no damn rerun…..
    So keep to steeping baby and say my NAME…..
    My men LOVE me baby….
    Did you know THAT???

    BITCHES AIN’T SHIT BUT HOES AND TRICKS
    They are so super sic in the street….
    and I give it to them because I can’t compete!
    I run the Damn SHOW HOE!!!!!
    A1 sauce is the BEST steak SAUCE but for his LOVE it cost baby!!!!!
    I represent the whole damn SHEBANG.,….
    it’s like Tang baby so say my name….

    Bulls baby we go REAL HARD and I can go HARDER if you want me too….
    now baby I just schooled you FOOL!!!!!

  5. As a child, Tyree Lived with his grandmother; Sandra Dorsey. She always kept her hair done and when she went to the hair salon, he went with her to get his hair cut.
    Ms.Dorsey’s hairstylist was a man who was also Tyree’s barber. It was then that he discovered his love for styling hair at 9 years old.
    Tai would always style the hair of his family members and it didn’t matter whether it was on a human head or on the heads of his toy troll dolls purchased by his mother and model Nicole Tate. Tyree had to style hair!
    Styling hair became second nature to Tyree when he was about eleven years old. By this time the hairstyles Tai was creating were good enough for his “clients” to wear outside of the house. Finally Tyree’s family realized he had a raw talent for styling hair.
    Tyree styled hair all through high school. He made his friends look like they had just walked out of the hair salon when leaving his home.
    After high school Tai became anxious to receive a license in the field of cosmetology. So he obtained professional instruction and perfected his craft by attending Rizzieri Schools for Beauty and Wellness located in Marlton, NJ.
    Tyree is a creative and innovative hair care technician who has been involved in cosmetology for 15 years, barbering for 5 years, and make-up for 5 years. He is the most sought after 25 year old stylist in the United States. His clientele includes the likes of Apostle Saundra L Hagagns, Kelly Price, Donna Richardson- Joyner, Twinkie Clark, Lexi, Dr Traci Lynn- Burton, Philadelphia news anchor Angela Russell, members of Sony Gospel recording artist Tye Tribbett and GA, many more
    Tyree is an award-winning stylist and has participated in several major hair competitions across America. He was also a featured stylist on the hit BETJ reality TV show “Tears, Shears, and Beauty.”
    Tyree is the founder of “Universal Stylist Inc”., the owner of “Tai Couture Salon”, and the president of the “Hair Oscars” association. He is a total image expert and if you are looking for that “star status” image Tai “The Universal Stylist” is the one for you!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: